Cecilia Bartoli’s Voice Between Heaven and the Underworld: Gluck’s Orfeo ed Euridice at Berlin’s Baroque Festival

On 12 November, as part of the Baroque Festival at the Staatsoper Unter den Linden, I attended a performance that marked my first encounter with Christoph Willibald Gluck’s opera Orfeo ed Euridice. And perhaps the highlight of the evening was the appearance of Cecilia Bartoli, who is not a frequent guest on Berlin’s stages but remains one of the most eagerly anticipated and beloved artists by local audiences.
The audience was presented with a semi-staged version of the opera, lasting approximately 90 minutes. This was not a fully staged production in the traditional sense: there were no elaborate sets or costumes, only a few scenic elements, projected background images and carefully considered directorial touches. Essentially, it was a concert performance with elements of theatrical staging. Yet the absence of elaborate scenery did nothing to diminish the atmosphere or the audience’s engagement throughout the evening.
On the contrary, the production was remarkably inventive and executed with great taste.

The architecture of the Staatsoper itself became part of the performance. When Orfeo descended into the Underworld, Cecilia Bartoli appeared on one of the balconies, calling out to the Furies. During the scenes in Elysium, she moved to one of the upper levels of the auditorium, drawing attention to the beauty of the surrounding world: look at the sky, look at the colours! She did not simply perform her role but actively interacted with the audience, drawing us into the story.
One particularly memorable moment came with Euridice’s return. When the character appeared, Bartoli quite literally ran down the staircase, her heels echoing through the auditorium. There was something so spontaneous, theatrical and charming about this small detail that it was impossible not to smile.
But, of course, the evening’s greatest attraction was Cecilia Bartoli herself. Her virtuoso coloratura, impeccable technique and expressiveness are astonishing, even for those accustomed to listening to her recordings. What impressed me most, however, was not simply her vocal performance but her extraordinary dramatic commitment and ability to immerse herself completely in the emotional world of the opera. Bartoli seemed to live Orfeo’s story rather than merely sing her part. Her voice and gestures conveyed despair, tenderness and genuine anguish. At one point, she even appeared close to tears as she mourned Euridice.

The roles of Euridice and Amore were performed by Mélissa Petit, whose contribution also made a very pleasant impression. The interaction between the two singers was one of the evening’s highlights, particularly in the emotionally charged scenes between Orfeo and Euridice.
As this was my first time hearing the opera, many of its musical passages felt like genuine discoveries. I particularly enjoyed the Chorus of the Furies, Orfeo’s aria, Euridice’s aria, the confrontation between Orfeo and the inhabitants of the Underworld, and the episode set in Elysium. Gluck’s music has a remarkable ability to combine dramatic tension with lyrical beauty. It possesses grandeur and delicacy, as well as a striking emotional immediacy.
I must admit that I was somewhat surprised by the musical language of the work. Although Gluck belongs to the Classical period and is best known for his operatic reforms, traces of the Baroque tradition are still very much present. This is particularly noticeable in the recitatives, certain musical passages and even some of the exchanges between characters, which occasionally introduce an unexpected comic element. The result is not simply a tragic story of love, loss and the impossibility of reclaiming the past, but a work that also leaves room for lightness and theatrical playfulness.

The ending deserves a special mention. I must confess that I kept hoping for a more optimistic outcome. At one point, I even wondered whether the production might offer its own interpretation of the myth and alter its conclusion. Instead, the final scenes left me with a sense of tragic incompleteness and became perhaps one of the most emotionally affecting moments of the evening.
Overall, it was a thoroughly enjoyable experience. Naturally, I would love to hear the complete version of the opera and see a fully staged production, but even in this shortened format, the work made a strong impression. The semi-staged concept proved not to be a limitation but rather an opportunity to focus on the music, the voices and the drama.
If you are not yet familiar with Gluck’s Orfeo ed Euridice, I highly recommend giving it a listen. And if you ever have the opportunity to hear Cecilia Bartoli live, do not hesitate.

Incidentally, on 4 June 2027, the Staatsoper Unter den Linden will welcome Cecilia Bartoli back to Berlin. This time, the singer will celebrate 40 years of her career with a concert performance of Gioachino Rossini’s The Barber of Seville. Gianluca Capuano will conduct, accompanied by the orchestra Les Musiciens du Prince – Monaco. Unfortunately, tickets were already sold out at the time of writing. If, like me, you dream of hearing Bartoli live, I would recommend keeping an eye on the theatre’s announcements in case additional tickets become available.
My next operatic destination is already on the list: La Calisto by Francesco Cavalli, one of my favourite composers and a pupil of Claudio Monteverdi. It seems that the Baroque Festival continues to open up new musical worlds for me.

Text: Julia Pneva
Photo: press department of Staatsoper Unter den Linden, Julia Pneva

Comments